Returns policy · page 1
“All returns require an unopened item and a valid purchase receipt. Opened items are not eligible for return.”
THE EVIDENCE LAB
You be the
second opinion.
Four small cases. Four kinds of judgment. Read the policy, make your call, and discover what the evidence actually establishes.
NO MODEL REQUIRED
An interactive exercise.
All policies are fictional.
THE VERDICT CHALLENGE0 / 4 EXPLORED
CASE 01The condition matters
THE CLAIM
“An opened item is eligible for return if the customer has a receipt.”
Judge only against the supplied packet. Don’t assume extra policies.
YOUR CALL
What does the evidence say?
Select a verdict to reveal the explanation.
No document upload. No AI request. No saved score.Why these four judgments?